Kate Rigby
For the next few weeks we will be diving into the topic of AI and it’s potential impact on authors. We’ve asked our authors the same questions in order to gauge their views and feelings on AI. Up first, award-winning author Kate Rigby.
1- Do you currently use any form of AI to enhance or improve your books and if so how do you feel it makes your writing better?
I’m assuming you mean generative AI, as I think we’ve all been using a form of AI for years without even considering it as this eg filters in Photoshop or other photography apps to enhance book covers, Word processors programmes like Word that use basic grammar, sentence correction/improvements and so on. For poetry, for instance, instead of physically cutting up pieces of paper you can get AI to ‘cut up’ sections for you.
Recently I tried using ChatCBT or similar for a short story synopsis as I didn’t know where to start and synopsis writing is not one of my skills! As this isn’t creative writing in the same sense (more highlighting themes and summarizing) I feel differently about it and see it as a useful tool. Even then, the summary that AI came up with I just used as a starting point.
2. How do you feel about AI in the creative industries in general, eg art, writing, music, are you in support or are you against? Tell us why.
Apart from the above uses eg as a tool, I’m pretty much opposed to it as are most ‘serious’ artists (in the wider sense) who have often taken years to hone their craft. I was horrified to see an ad come through my newsfeed from Amazon advertising about writing books with AI. As if there weren’t too many of us already trying to chase an ever-shrinking audience as it is!
I have heard one or two neurodiverse authors say they have used AI and it’s helped them but I feel very uneasy about it. Surely creativity comes from something that has moved and inspired us to create and convey a feeling or human experience? For me it would depend on whether they are using it as an aid or to generate content. I feel too many people just think of it as an easy and fast way to make money and have instant success without putting in the hard yards. That isn’t art, but painting – or writing – by numbers. Besides which, I’m hugely opposed to it on ethical grounds. It’s been trained on all the content out there without permission so it’s theft of intellectual property.
There’s also the environmental toll of using AI and how much energy is needed.
3. How often are you coming across AI content on the internet now and are you usually able to spot it?
I sometimes see eg in writers’ forums people posting their book covers and asking for feedback. Luckily, a lot of the contributors in the discussion can spot AI a mile off and frown upon its use. The people I’ve seen posting are quite open about using it and maybe haven’t thought of the moral arguments. But it’s already becoming harder and harder to spot as generative AI becomes more sophisticated. Most people say they can tell because there is something soulless about it eg book covers. The same has been said of writing. For this reason, I’m very glad I write non-genre fiction which is less formulaic, ergo harder to generate. It’s the same with poetry. AI will come up with rhyming poetry rather than free verse. (See last question). So if you write more quirky stuff, you are ‘safer’. At least, for now.
On the other hand it may have uses for audiobooks. Many authors are prohibited from converting their books to audio books because it’s time consuming and labour intensive and ergo very expensive. This would be good work for actors but notoriously difficult to find the right reader. At the moment AI isn’t up to the mark for generating spoken content for audiobooks, especially where accents and dialect is concerned. But I could possibly see benefits in the future (but see below re performance art).
4. Do you know of any creatives who have already lost their job or seen their earnings decline thanks to AI?
I think it’s a creeping thing. I’ve heard of eg editors and proofreaders getting less work. I’m sure the same is happening with book designers and certainly there was the whole issue on Hollywood where actors and performers were on strike because they were no longer being paid for their work. AI generated voices were used instead.
I once entered a poetry competition where the feedback was generated by AI! Though a lot of the feedback was uplifting I felt uneasy about it. I don’t know how much of it was used for the judging. Did the human judges assess first or did they rely on AI to weed out the long and short lists?
I notice some online publishing sites and stock photography sites don’t accept the AI images. However such sites are having to rely on trust from contributors as it gets ever more and more sophisticated and hard to tell apart.
5. Copy writers and translators are just two professions that have seen their earnings decline as companies switch to using AI. Who do you think will be next and is there anything we can do to stop it?
There’s a big discussion in the music industry as well as the other creative industries. We are already seeing how the sound and voices of real musicians can be replicated very convincingly.
6. What are your gut feelings about AI in creative writing? Are you curious and excited by the possibilities, or do you think it spells the death knell for creativity and imagination?
I fear it to be honest. I do see potential for audio books because if we could, many of us would produce these ourselves if we had the time and equipment so wouldn’t be taking jobs away from others. I think it’s fine to use as AI as a tool but never as a replacement or to generate something from scratch. But I can see boundaries becoming more and more blurred.
7. Would you personally read AI content if you knew it was AI or do you aim to only read books written by humans without the aid of AI?
I would like to think I would only read that generated by humans but I know of someone who’s quite openly mentioned using AI for poetry. I was quite shocked although I know this person to be honest and with integrity. People who’ve grown up with it may not have the same moral dilemma as older people do.
8. Where do you think AI will be in another 5, 10 years time?
I’m hoping that changing the copyright laws may at least go some way to retstrain it although it may be very difficult to prove as the genie’s already out of the bottle. But at the moment it’s like the wild west with no protections or limits. I think we have no choice but to accept it and work with it as it’s here to stay.
9. Do you think AI in creative writing will ultimately be a bad or a good thing for writers?
I guess we have a chance to make it work for us rather than the other way round. There was an interesting podcast which was summarised recently in Disability Arts Online looking at the pros and cons particularly for disabled people.
10. Use this last question to voice any concerns about AI specifically in creative writing
I think I will show here rather than tell. Out of curiosity, I fed in a few lines from my notebooks on two separate occasions a year or so ago and asked AI to write a poem based on those few lines which were:
light spillage
echolocating animals emit calls out to the environment and listen to the echoes of those calls that return from various objects near them
This was the resulting AI poem. I will leave readers to make up their own minds:
In the realm where darkness lies,
A symphony of sound takes flight,
Echolocating creatures take their aim,
To navigate a world untamed.
With calls that pierce the still of night,
They unleash waves of sonic might,
Through vast expanses they explore,
Guided by echoes they adore.
Like beams of light, their calls spill forth,
Bouncing off objects, revealing their course,
In the reverberations, secrets unfold,
A tapestry of knowledge, yet untold.
With every echo, the world they perceive,
Each sound a clue to help them achieve,
Survival’s dance in shadows deep,
As echolocating wonders they keep.
Oh, let their example light your way,
Let inspiration guide you each passing day,
Embrace the echoes, let them be your guide,
In this vast universe where wonders reside.
Thank you for inviting me to be part of this important discussion.
Links:
Website: https://kjrbooks.yolasite.com/
Facebook page: https://www.facebook.com/authorrigby
Blog: https://authisticwords.blogspot.com/
Instagram: https://instagram.com/kate_jay_r
TikTok: https://vm.tiktok.com/ZGJTtmSAk/
YouTube: https://youtube.com/@TheBubbity
Amazon: https://www.amazon.co.uk/stores/Kate-Rigby/author/B001KDR9GE
Thanks so much for joining us Kate! Next week, author Chantelle Atkins will be sharing her views on the rise of AI in creative writing.
Chasing Driftwood Books 
Wonderful ♥️
LikeLike